As many of you know, Tom Cruise has been in the news lately for some very controversial comments about the field of
psychiatry.
He has been apt to call people who disagree with him misinformed, but as you see from today’s blog entry, Tom Cruise is the one who is misinformed.
Cruise recently told a reporter:
"I think psychiatry should be outlawed. I can't believe electric shock therapy is still used. I think it definitely does more harm than good." He recently told the magazine
Entertainment Weekly (June 17, 2005 issue) that
“People are being electric shocked. Kids are being drugged. People are dying.”Psychiatry should be outlawed? People are dying? I work with
psychiatrists every week since I am often called to evaluate their patients, on both an inpatient and outpatient basis. The notion that the services they provide are so harmful that the entire field needs to be outlawed is entirely without merit. I am not a psychiatrist and I do not prescribe medication, but I have seen time and time and again how psychiatric medication does help many people. Sometimes, it’s a lifesaver. Tom, you are the one who is misinformed.
Of course some people are overmedicated, but this is not a problem unique to psychiatry. I just saw a patient on a rehabilitation unit last week who was on over 20 medications. So should we ban rehabilitation medicine too, Tom? And by the way, psychiatrists are NOT the physicians who are prescribing most psychiatric medications. Most people get anti-depressants, anti-anxiety medications, and stimulants for attention deficit disorder from
general practice physicians or
family practitioners. So should we ban those medical fields too?
People die from medication-related side effects every day. That’s not to say it is right or acceptable, but once again, it is not a problem unique to psychiatry. But for some reason, Tom Cruise has chosen to single out one particular field and attack it relentlessly. So we must ask ourselves why that would be. Well, Tom Cruise is a scientologist and his religion has been assailing psychiatry for decades. Some scientology books even refer to psychiatry as a “Nazi science.” This article is not written to attack scientology, but someone needs to put Tom’s comments into perspective.
I am the first to admit that psychiatry has a checkered past due to how inpatients were mistreated in asylums and given lobotomies and shock treatments when much more humane treatments would have sufficed. But that was the past. It’s not the present. Shock treatment is rarely used today and is reserved for patients whom all other treatments have failed, such as severe depression or severe obsessive compulsive disorder. Not only is shock treatment rarely used today, but when it is used, it is done under very controlled circumstances and is far safer than the past.
The idea Tom Cruise is creating is that psychiatrists these days run around strapping people into electric chairs and shocking them against their will. Does anyone really believe that? Incidentally, patients that receive shock treatment are advised in detail about the procedure and need to sign informed consent forms before the procedure is used. Tom Cruise frequently refers to psychiatric medication as anti-psychotics, when in reality, they are only one type of psychiatric medication reserved specifically for patients who are psychotic (those who have impaired reality testing, such as hearing voices). Most psychiatric medications prescribed in the U.S. are anti-depressants or anti-anxiety medications and are not classified as antipsychotics. These are facts. Tom, you are the one who is misinformed.
Tom Cruise has backed up his Nazi-psychiatry comments by stating that the famous Swiss psychiatrist, Carl Jung (1875-1961), was a Nazi sympathizer. While it is true that Carl Jung was interested in the Nazi movement in terms of studying his theories of human behavior (i.e., the collective unconscious), he clearly rejected the gruesome aspects of the Nazi movement when they came to light. In fact, Jung’s anti-Nazi and anti-Hitler views were so clearly stated that he was placed on the Nazi blacklist and his comments were suppressed in Germany. Tom Cruise stated numerous times to Matt Lauer on the Today Show that he knows the history of psychiatry and that others are misinformed about the matter. Tom, you are the one who is misinformed.
Tom Cruise tried to make another Nazi-psychiatry link by saying that the drug methadone (which is used to treat heroin addictions) was originally named Adolophine, after Adolf Hitler. Well, according to the Dictionary of Drugs and Medicine, the drug’s original name was actually dolophine (not adolophine), which comes from the Latin word “dolor” for pain and “fin” for end or finish. Tom, you are the one who is misinformed.
Tom Cruise has also said psychiatry is a pseudoscience and that it is not based on research. There are numerous scientific journals strictly dedicated to rigorous psychiatric research. So once again Tom, you are the one who is misinformed. I can go on and on, but I think I have proven my point and helped you understand the motivation of the messenger.
Let me end by saying that Tom Cruise is not misinformed when he says shock treatments and medications do not get to the root of the problem as to why someone is depressed, anxious, etc. They treat the
symptoms. Psychotherapy (i.e., talk therapy) helps get at the root of the probelms. Time and time and again, research has shown that the combination of medication and psychotherapy is more effective than either treatment alone. I am all for getting people off of medications if they do not need it and advocate trying non-medication treatments first, if possible. But there is a proper way to discuss these things, Tom, and making outlandish accusations against decent people and acting like a know-it-all is not the way to go about it.